An MBTA employee stands outside the Commuter Rail fare gates at North Station. (Kate Kotlyar/CommonWealth Beacon)

LAWMAKERS HAVE VIRTUALLY no say over which outside company the MBTA will hire to run its sprawling commuter rail network when the current massive contract expires next year.

They will, however, quickly be called into action to help foot the bill.

The MBTA’s current deal with commuter rail operator Keolis became the largest operating contract in state history when it was awarded in 2014. Since then, its value has swelled to nearly $6 billion — more than $1 billion above initial estimates — and roughly 20 percent of the T’s annual operating budget now goes toward paying for the commuter rail.

The price tag is expected to be quite a bit higher in the next iteration, which will land as the MBTA continues to grapple with a sizable gap between its revenues and spending every year despite a series of one-time investments from Beacon Hill.

To many of those eagerly awaiting word on who will win, there’s no choice but for the state to grin and bear it.

“These are not investments that we can afford not to make,” said Kate Dineen, president of the business-backed group A Better City. “This is likely to be a very sizable contract, but think about what we’re getting for that contract. Think about the benefits that the commuter rail of today and the commuter rail of five to 10 years from now are going to deliver for our region.”

There’s a lot riding on the deal: The commuter rail network transports more than 115,000 passengers per weekday on average, and unlike the buses and subways, its 700 miles of track across 12 lines stretch well beyond the Boston metropolitan area, serving as a key conduit for housing and job centers.

MBTA higher-ups plan to make a recommendation of who should win the contract when the agency’s board of directors meets publicly in December. Board members could vote then and there to seal the deal, which would give the winner a bit more than six months to prepare before the July 1, 2027, start date.

Three consortiums submitted bids: Keolis, in a partnership with British firm Amey Ltd.; Mass Regional Rail, which includes the firm that ran the commuter rail for more than a decade until it was replaced by Keolis in 2014; and Transdev North America, part of the same multinational company in charge of the controversial Boston Public Schools bus contract.

The T operates its own buses and subways, but it has long contracted outthe commuter rail system. MBTA officials originally expected their agreement with Keolis — which 12 years ago underbid the incumbent — would top out at a cost of around $355 million per year. In fiscal year 2026, the T in fact spent $621 million on commuter rail, about one-fifth of its entire operating expenses, according to a budget update presented last month.

Brian Kane, executive director of the watchdog MBTA Advisory Board, said officials have learned by now that many bids involve “a certain amount of blue smoke and mirrors.” He’s estimated the new deal could surpass $10 billion.

“When Keolis underbid last time, I think there was a sense that was a number that could actually be achieved. The MBTA was very quickly relieved of that knowledge,” Kane said. “Frankly, coming into this new bid, I think that experience has been frontloaded, so I hope that whatever number comes out is a more realistic number.”

This time around, the procurement baked in one mechanism in particular that could alter the math: After one year, the winning operator will have a chance to update what it charges to account for any unforeseen developments. Whatever the deal is starting in July 2027, that price might change.

On top of that, the costs of running the commuter rail will continue to rise as pay raises guaranteed in union contracts take effect and as the price of diesel — which powers all of the T’s current commuter rail trains — skyrockets amid the US war in Iran.

All of that will inevitably collide with a stark fiscal reality: For a generation, the MBTA has struggled to bring in more moneyin revenue than it spends. Beacon Hill has directed significantly more funding toward the agency in recent years, but policymakers continue to lean on one-time injections with no guarantee they will maintain the level of aid from one year to the next.

A significantly bigger line item to pay for commuter rail could widen the gap at a time when state government is already struggling to offset federal funding losses elsewhere.

“It’s going to put continued pressure on the Legislature to come up with additional funds for the MBTA on an annual basis, which they’re just going to have to do,” said Stephen Silveira, a senior vice president at ML Strategies who chaired the Massachusetts Transportation Finance Commission in the mid-2000s. “If the contracts come in more expensive — quite frankly, even if they came in at the current rate — the pressure’s going to be on the Legislature and the governor to come up with that money, because right now, I don’t feel confident that the money’s there.”

Some worry locking in higher costs for the commuter rail system could come at the expense of improvements to the T’s core bus and subway services, especially with a persistent budget gap. Arguably, the commuter rail is already subsidized at a disproportionate rate: It carries about 12 percent of the T’s riders yet receives 20 percent of its operating dollars.

“Every penny that goes to the new operator is not going to making the buses better, is not going to hiring more bus operators so they can run more service, is not going to the Better Bus Network, which to me is as important as commuter rail,” added Stephanie Pollack, a former state transportation secretary and now a senior fellow at the MIT Mobility Institute. (Pollack is also a Greg Torres senior fellow at MassINC, the nonprofit that publishes CommonWealth Beacon.)

For skeptics of the T’s ballooning budget, the forthcoming commuter rail decision underlines structural problems that need attention. The Pioneer Institute, a free market-oriented think tank, last year published a report criticizing how quickly MBTA operating expenses rose in the years after the COVID-19 pandemic began and suggested the agency was paying far more than its peers on areas such as buses.

“It all costs too much,” said Charlie Chieppo, one of the report’s authors, in an interview. “I have no problem with paying 10 percent more or 20 percent more to make the T work better. I have a problem paying 50 percent more than people do in other places for reasons that are easily solved,” he said, citing as an example a strained retirement system.

Even if the T’s budget continues to run in the red, state policymakers are less wary of giving the agency more money than they were a decade ago. Gov. Maura Healey and her deputies have made a point to criticize their predecessors for “underinvestment” in transit after the early-2020s nadir of slow zones and federal safety investigations.

That could set the stage for officials to pick a costlier commuter rail bid if they feel there are strong enough upsides for service, especially with an eye toward efforts to electrify and modernize the system that will unfold in the coming years.

“I think what’s top of mind for the deciding folks on this contract is not necessarily getting the cheapest or the lowest,” said Kane, whose group represents cities and towns who help fund the T. “It’s getting the best value, and I think that’s a different approach at the highest level.”

Chris Lisinski covers Beacon Hill, transportation and more for CommonWealth Beacon. After growing up in New York and then graduating from Boston University, Chris settled in Massachusetts and spent...