To the casual observer, the 1998 race for governor may have looked like a two-man face-off back in the middle of May. That’s when Acting Governor Paul Cellucci and Attorney General Scott Harshbarger took to the television airwaves–on the same day–and launched their advertising campaigns.

Both candidates wanted to move early to get voters ready for a Harshbarger vs. Cellucci contest. After all, the Republican Party had shown overwhelming support for Cellucci at the state convention in April, and Harshbarger was well on his way to lining up majority support at the June Democratic convention.

But when it comes to politics in Massachusetts, it’s not always over when it seems over. Neither party has a final nominee until the voters take part in the primaries on Sept. 15. Fresh from victory at his party’s convention, Cellucci nevertheless had no guarantee that the state’s Republican voters wouldn’t turn around in September and hand the nomination to his rival, state Treasurer Joe Malone. Nor could he be sure the Democrat on the general election ballot would be Harshbarger–and not former state senator Patricia McGovern, or even former congressman Brian Donnelly.

It’s happened before: The Democratic convention in 1990 went for Francis X. Bellotti–but the primary voters chose John Silber. The Republican convention that year elevated then-Rep. Steven Pierce, but the primary voters liked upstart candidate William F. Weld.

Most states sort all this out in the spring or summer. Massachusetts has one of the latest primaries in the nation–only Hawaii and Louisiana come later this year.

Why is the state primary so late in the year?

In California, gubernatorial candidates were preparing for their June primary back in December, airing television ads months before some Massachusetts candidates had even decided to run. Illinois, Ohio, and Texas hold their primaries in March, giving party nominees more than seven months to battle it out before the final election.

The autumn primary in Massachusetts means that until just seven weeks before the general election candidates are simultaneously fighting an intra-party battle and trying to undercut their rivals from the other side.

Then, after the primary, campaigns have to change gears quickly. “You have only 47 days to focus on your general election opponent. That’s not a lot of time,” says Gus Bickford, who is executive director (on leave) of the state Democratic Party.

That’s been a problem for many candidates over the years. Republican John Sears still talks about being caught off guard in 1982 when former Gov. Michael S. Dukakis upset then-Gov. Ed King in the Democratic primary. Sears suddenly had to rearrange his campaign to face a more liberal opponent in November.

Some people complain that fall primaries unfairly favor incumbents. “In the months before the primary, candidates are often forced to mount a grueling, expensive campaign that leaves them drained,” says political analyst Jon Keller. All of the advantages that usually accompany incumbency–better name recognition, bigger war chests, etc.–get magnified when it’s a short sprint to the general election.

In 1994, Gov. William Weld decided to campaign against all of the Democrats trying to unseat him–Mark Roosevelt, George Bachrach, and Michael Barrett–before he knew who his challenger would be. “He didn’t want to take the chance of waiting, so he started running television ads in the summer against all three of them,” says Marc DeCourcey, executive director of the state Republican Party. “We would have preferred to know we would be up against Roosevelt far earlier.” Though Weld easily defeated Roosevelt in the general election, he expended precious time, money, and energy on the other Democrats.

Late-season primaries may complicate campaign strategy, but some observers say they are better for voters. “For most citizens, politics is not a year-round occupation. They start to focus on candidates in August or early September,” says Secretary of State William Galvin.

Thus spring primaries can require candidates to gear their messages more toward the party faithful. A campaign for a fall primary is about appealing to a broader spectrum of voters. “It’s more democratic,” Galvin says.

But it wasn’t populist impulses on the part of Massachusetts lawmakers that led to the compact election season. Galvin, a student of electoral history, said primaries were introduced here in the 1920s, when governors served two-year terms. A spring primary would have forced the next campaign to start too soon after the newly elected governor took the oath of office.

Despite some grumblings about the state’s political calendar, there have been no serious attempts to change it.

Suffolk University government professor John Berg can think of just a few disadvantages. In presidential selection years, it can be election overload, he says. The presidential primary is held in the spring and tends to depress voter turnout for the state primary in September, when legislative and congressional candidates are chosen. Then there’s the summer factor–some voters aren’t ready to pay attention to a primary that comes so close to vacation, Berg says.

But on balance, he concludes: “Our system makes sense.”

David Mason, a senior fellow at the conservative Heritage Foundation in Washington, D.C., says that across the country those who work in politics all year long are comfortable with what they’ve got. “They understand their systems and they’re used to living with it,” Mason says. “Why bother to change?”

Lauren Markoe is the State House Bureau Chief for The Patriot Ledger of Quincy.