The colors are bright, the ads are popping, and promises of free money encourage you to just try out a bit of online gambling. Welcome to a vision of the online state lottery, which is making serious strides toward becoming reality in Massachusetts with the blessing of one legislative chamber and the new governor.
Don’t look to the state’s top prosecutor to break ranks.
Attorney General Andrea Campbell’s office is giving the side eye to the online lottery for almost the same reasons she called for stricter regulation of online sports betting, but the attorney general stops short of saying the state shouldn’t take the plunge into online lottery sales.
“AG Campbell’s office does not oppose online gaming, but we demand safe and responsible conduct of all operators, including the Lottery,” a spokeswoman for Campbell said in a statement.
Campbell’s recent warnings about mobile sports betting, which launched in the Commonwealth last month, had a dire ring to them.
“We already know it can be an area that can lead to addiction, and of course addictive use, which can lead to mental health concerns, substance use disorder, you name it,” Campbell said last month. “And so our job is to protect the consumers.”
Put the office’s list of concerns about mobile sports betting up against the concerns about the online lottery, and you may think you’re seeing double.
Campbell’s deputies waved red flags before the Massachusetts Gaming Commission about sports betting platform designs, user data collection, push alerts that could encourage habitual and harmful gambling, targeted advertising, and the risks of attracting young people who cannot legally place bets. Her office is looking at those same risk factors in the “iLottery.”
“Safety and responsibility is a priority for our office and we look forward to hearing details on what types of games an online lottery proposes to offer, how it will be marketed to consumers, and how responsible use can be encouraged and addictive elements mitigated,” the spokeswoman said.
Unlike mobile sports betting, however, the online lottery is not yet the law of the land. If Campbell wanted to wade in and oppose its legalization while still enforcing whatever law passes, she could take a leaf from then-AG Healey’s playbook on recreational cannabis.
That would mean bucking the governor, who has been a close political ally and backed Campbell as her successor to the attorney general post in 2022. And Healey thinks an online lottery will help make the state more competitive.
“We have casinos in the state. We also have DraftKings here in the state, and a lot of money is being spent there by a lot of people,” Healey said to GBH’s Jim Braude. “What we also have is a lottery system that right now isn’t able to compete against a DraftKings. Nothing against DraftKings, but the Lottery, that’s money coming back to cities and towns. The money spent on DraftKings is going to DraftKings.”
The Massachusetts lottery is a massive revenue driver for the state, bringing in $1.1 billion in net profit in Fiscal Year 2022, according to the state treasurer’s office. The Bay State has the distinction of its lottery revenues making up the highest proportion of its gross domestic product of any US state.
If the explosive start to online sports betting in Massachusetts was any indicator, there is a profound appetite for gambling on mobile platforms. The Lottery had been raring to move online, worrying that it would be left behind in the mobile gambling space.
Mark Bracken, the interim Massachusetts State Lottery director, told MassLive that the state lottery app has functionality built in to incorporate an online lottery if lawmakers approve the gambling expansion.
After fizzling out in an economic development package last session, a renewed push for a Massachusetts iLottery found a friendly audience in the House of Representatives and Healey. The House’s budget proposal, passed Wednesday and on its way to the Senate, would legalize online Lottery sales with an expected $200 million in new revenue directed toward early education and child care grants.
JENNIFER SMITH
NEW STORIES FROM COMMONWEALTH MAGAZINE
Empty picture frame: Governors traditionally feature a picture of one of their favorite predecessors behind their desk at the State House, but Gov. Maura Healey is instead hanging an empty picture frame. Healey said she hopes the empty frame, inspired by a student essay competition, will encourage visitors to her office to envision themselves inside the frame. Read more.
Default on wind farm: Avangrid CEO, in a talk with financial analysts, mentions the company has defaulted on a provision in its offshore wind contract with three Massachusetts utilities. A default isn’t that surprising given Avangrid’s decision to walk away from the contract because of changed economic circumstances. Read more.
Opaque budget process: The House follows its opaque budget process of assembling mega-amendments in private and then passing them with little debate on the House floor. One amendment in consolidated amendment E raised the salary of governor’s councilors by $9,000. Read more.
OPINION
Joint effort: Regional HUD administrator Juana Matias says cross-sector partnerships are key to addressing problems, such as student homelessness in Lawrence. Read more.
STORIES FROM ELSEWHERE AROUND THE WEB
MUNICIPAL MATTERS
The Easthampton School Committee puts its search for a new superintendent on hold after offers to the first two candidates were withdrawn in a process that has drawn national attention. (Daily Hampshire Gazette)
The Gloucester City Council votes to raise the salary of the mayor by $15,000 to $115,000. (Gloucester Times)
The North Brookfield Select Board said a local Pride event can move forward with a drag performance on the town common, even without the permission of the board. (Worcester Telegram)
HEALTH/HEALTH CARE
More than a week after a ransomware attack, Point32Health, the parent company of Harvard Pilgrim Health Care and Tufts Health Plan, is still being hobbled by its effects. (Boston Globe)
ELECTIONS
Neil Harrington and Dominick Pangallo square off in a debate in the race for mayor of Salem. Harrington is a former mayor of Salem and town manager in Salisbury. Pangallo was the chief of staff to former mayor and now Lt. Gov. Kim Driscoll. (Salem News)
EDUCATION
The Boston Public Schools is rehiring accounting giant Ernst & Young to audit its exam school admissions after the district’s switch to a small, Sharon-based firm to handle the work resulted in multiple errors. (Boston Globe)
ENERGY/ENVIRONMENT
A draft report from the US Environmental Protection Agency finds a proposed machine gun range on Joint Base Cape Cod would threaten drinking water in the area and represent a “significant public health hazard.” (GBH)
CRIMINAL JUSTICE/COURTS
The Supreme Judicial Court ruled that breath tests used to detect blood alcohol levels cannot be used in roughly 27,000 past DUI convictions because the machines were not reliable. The ruling does not throw out the convictions but clears the way for those affected to seek a new trial. (Boston Globe)
Charles Lieber, a former Harvard University chemistry professor, is sentenced to six months home confinement and ordered to pay a $50,000 fine after being convicted of concealing his financial ties to the Chinese government. (GBH)
Holyoke officials are reviewing the effectiveness of using ShotSpotter gunfire detection technology in parts of the city. The tech detected 39 gunshots around downtown Holyoke in March, after which zero people were reported injured and seven arrests were made. (MassLive)
A fatal road rage incident In Belmont, in which a man allegedly hurled a racial slur at another before driving over him with a pickup truck two years ago, is now before a jury. (MetroWest Daily News)
MEDIA
The Globe posted a second correction (see end of story) to a Sunday article that slammed MBTA officials for working remotely. The first correction backtracked on the suggestion that Dennis Lytton, the deputy safety chief, was working from Los Angeles, and the second said Michele Stiehler, the chief of paratransit services, was not working from New Jersey.
Northeastern journalism professor Dan Kennedy says the Globe’s use of private information provided by online commenters to try to track down the City Hall source of vitriolic comments attacking Mayor Michelle Wu and other city officials makes him “a little queasy” but he concludes it was OK to do. (Media Nation)