Attorney General Andrea Campbell has been reluctant to dive head-first into the debate over whether to move state lottery games online, steering clear of unconditional support or opposition to such a move. But she continues to wade in on the issue in ways that signal a wariness toward expanding the state-run gambling enterprise. What’s more, her latest comments suggest the AG’s concerns may be centered on the very type of online games lottery officials want to launch to draw in younger players. 

Lottery officials have been pushing for years to expand their offerings beyond ticket sales at brick-and-mortar retail outlets. The launch earlier this year of online sports betting has only intensified that call. 

The House responded by tucking an outside section into its 2024 budget proposal authorizing online lottery, but the Senate did not follow suit. That makes it one of several contentious issues that must be resolved in closed-door negotiations now underway in a six-member House-Senate conference committee. 

Gov. Maura Healey, who opposed casino gambling in the past, has said she would support online lottery to boost the Bay State’s competitiveness, taking up lottery officials’ line that the state needs to keep up with online sports betting. 

With the fate of the issue unclear, Campbell reiterated her concerns yesterday and said online lottery, if approved, should be restricted to players who are at least 21 years old. Lottery ticket buyers at retail outlets only have to be 18. 

“As we emphasized in the context of mobile sports betting, all online gambling, no matter who is offering it, presents significant consumer protection and public health issues,” Campbell said in a statement. “We must have guardrails in place, including safe and responsible app design and game offerings, 21+ age restrictions to protect our schools and young people, and marketing that informs consumers rather than misleads them. Our office pushed for these requirements from private mobile gaming operators and we must require at least as much from the state itself.”

What Campbell means by “safe and responsible app design and game offerings” isn’t clear, but it suggests concern over the very kind of game offerings anticipated here and currently offered in the seven other states with online lotteries. Those include instant online “scratch” ticket games at price points ranging from 10 cents to $20 that can, as CommonWealth reported earlier this year, “have the energy of a slot machine.” 

That slot machine energy seems to be what Campbell is worried about. It’s what concerned Sen. John Keenan of Quincy during the Senate budget debate. He questioned the push to expand gambling, saying we know that it is “highly addictive” and “hits the same receptors in the brain as does an opioid.” 

Campbell seems to be staking out ground that tilts against online lottery – without directly opposing it – perhaps because she’s not eager, in her first year in office, to go up against House leadership or the governor who played a big role in getting her elected.

Retail store owners are strongly opposed to online lottery, which they fear will cut into their sale of lottery tickets. Lottery officials have insisted that won’t happen and that online lottery will target a new and younger market. 

“We’re trying to attract a new and emerging generation, and there’s a sense of urgency and a sense of immediate gratification that this emerging generation has,” Mark Bracken, the lottery director, said during an April legislative hearing on online lottery. 

Whether the state wants to expand the pool of gamblers for its games, with the new revenue as well as addiction problems that come with it, is the question lawmakers have to answer. 

MICHAEL JONAS

FROM COMMONWEALTH

Ghost guns: Attorney General Andrea Campbell adds her voice to those seeking a crackdown on so-called ghost guns, untraceable homemade firearms lacking serial numbers or other identifying marks. Read more. 

OPINION

On the wrong path: Jim Jordan, the retired director of strategic planning at the Boston Police Department, says we’re losing the War on Drugs with the latest evidence being research suggesting more drug busts are simply leading to more overdoses. Read more.

 

FROM AROUND THE WEB

BEACON HILL

Ride-hailing drivers and their legislative supporters rally at the State House for legislation that would allow the drivers to unionize. (State House News Service)

The state has been pocketing federal benefits meant for minors in its care, a practice some state lawmakers are looking to change. (Boston Globe) 

State Auditor Diana DiZoglio has faced stiff resistance from House Speaker Ron Mariano and Senate President Karen Spilka to her plan to audit the Legislature, but the Republican she trounced to win the seat last fall, Anthony Amore, is cheering for her. (Boston Globe) 

MUNICIPAL MATTERS  

Boston Mayor Michelle Wu said recent charges against City Councilors Ricardo Arroyo and Kendra Lara have hurt the council’s credibility. (Boston Herald) 

Wu says it’s a challenge to get people to abandon cars for a more climate-friendly – but currently unreliable – public transit system. (Boston Globe)

Great Barrington is considering a real estate transfer fee paid by buyers and sellers to support the development of affordable housing. (Berkshire Eagle)

Area pols are pushing the city to move faster with approvals needed to open L Street Beach in South Boston, which has been closed due to nesting by endangered piping plovers. (Boston Herald) 

HEALTH/HEALTH CARE

Boston Medical Center is ending a policy that allowed families without housing, many of them immigrants, to stay at the hospital. One night last week 130 people slept on the floor in one of the hospital’s lobbies. Hospital officials are sending the families to Logan Airport. (WBUR)

BUSINESS/ECONOMY

State gaming regulators reject a bid by DraftKings to add Liv Golf to its gambling options. The regulators cited several reasons, including the golf league’s ties to the Saudi government. (State House News Service)

Amazon’s Worcester warehouse, purchased in 2019, still has not started operations despite the company paying about $450,000 in property tax on the site. (Worcester Telegram)

TRANSPORTATION

The Daily Item dispatches reporters to find the best way into Boston from Lynn and discovers, in terms of time, the commuter rail is tops, followed by driving a car, taking the Blue Line, and boarding the ferry.

CRIMINAL JUSTICE/COURTS

A Brockton school cop is suing the school district’s superintendent, a school committee member, and another former employee for alleged retaliation. (The Enterprise of Brockton)