THE STORY IN in the Sunday sports section said it all: High school football teams on Cape Cod are at risk of folding because they can’t get enough students to participate.
Football programs are challenged everywhere because of concerns around head injuries, but on the Cape the issue is different. Schools are having trouble fielding full teams because the year-round population here is dwindling. Families are being crowded out of housing as vacation homes and seasonal rentals continue to surge in a post-pandemic trend that has not ebbed almost seven years on.
Even more telling is that the team referenced in the story is Dennis-Yarmouth Regional High School. While Outer Cape communities such as Provincetown or Lower Cape communities like Chatham have had trouble fielding sports teams of all types for years, Dennis and Yarmouth are Mid-Cape communities that have always had a steady year-round population.
The year-round working family on the Cape, composed of parents who hold vital jobs in health care, hospitality, or as public safety workers and children enrolled in public schools, is headed for extinction. They are being replaced by affluent individuals who buy seasonal homes on the Cape to use for a few months of the year and investors who can make six figures placing their homes on short-term rental platforms.
Evidence of the affluent buyer and investor trends is easy to spot: In August, 40 percent of all Cape real estate transactions involved a cash buyer. Nationally, the figure is less than 30 percent. The inventory of available homes is shrinking, too. Between 2025 and 2026, according to August data, 6 percent fewer single-family homes were listed.
To really get a picture of what the future looks like, all one needs to do is look across Nantucket Sound. The Nantucket Public Schools just hit its lowest enrollment numbers in a decade. Meanwhile, between 2016 and 2025, the average sale price of a home grew from $1.47 million to $3.45 million. Homes selling for less than $1 million no longer come on the market, and homes under $2 million list very infrequently. Nantucket is Cape Cod’s canary in the coal mine.
In just 10 years, Wellfleet’s elementary school enrollment will fall by 6 percent. A recent study raised the possibility of closing the town’s sole elementary school and sending young learners to neighboring communities. It would be the first town on the Cape to have no elementary school.
Up the road in Harwich, in what was once one of the Cape’s more affordable communities for year-round workers, the town was just named the “hottest zip code” in Massachusetts for real estate sales and the third hottest zip code in the nation. The average sale price is now $1.4 million.
The latest Cape housing data should serve as a clarion call. Action is urgently needed before we lose something special that we can never truly get back.
There is no single solution to this problem. Rather, an array of incremental but targeted steps can create new positive momentum.
New regional revenue sources need to be considered to stabilize the market in seasonal communities and give local families a fairer shot at affording a home.
A comprehensive review of zoning on the Cape, including the minimum lot size to build a home, is essential. While Question 7, which would have allowed starter homes on lots of 5,000 square feet or more, was narrowly defeated this month by voters statewide, it was supported by voters in three Outer Cape towns that have seen major losses in year-round inventory.
The economic development bill being hammered out by a legislative conference committee includes a provision in the House version – Yes, In God’s Back Yard – that would allow housing development on the property of faith-based organizations. With an abundance of churches across the Cape, and congregations that are shrinking, this is a practical solution that can make the best use of spare land.
The conference committee is also considering a Senate provision allowing duplexes as of right, so that communities could no longer mandate single-family zoning. This would specifically allow families living and working on the Cape to convert their home to a duplex and allow the next generation to put down roots on the very same parcel.
The Cape is at a crossroads. Nobody truly benefits from a seasonal playground where working families can’t thrive and schools can’t field an athletic team. We can and must do better. Our future depends on it.
Alisa Magnotta is the CEO of Housing Assistance on Cape Cod.
CommonWealth Voices is sponsored by The Boston Foundation.
The Boston Foundation is deeply committed to civic leadership, and essential to our work is the exchange of informed opinions. We are proud to partner on a platform that engages such a broad range of demographic and ideological viewpoints.

