Middle house - 112 Dedham - was built in 1951.
A section of Dedham Street in Canton is lined with modest-sized starter homes built in the early 1950s. Builders say it's become impossible to construct these homes today in Greater Boston. (Photo by Michael Jonas)

GIVEN THE SCALE of the housing problem in Massachusetts, a well-crafted remedy should win in a landslide. And yet, Question 7 failed at the polls, despite being pitched as a “starter homes” accelerant.

Question 7 would have set the statewide minimum lot size requirement for new single-family homes at 5,000 square feet for parcels with adequate street frontage and access to public water and sewer services.

Its rejection on November 3 wasn’t due to “ballot fatigue,” as some proponents have dismissively claimed. It failed because it was a poorly designed blunt instrument applied to a complex problem, and voters saw through the clever marketing to recognize its flaws.

Question 7 presumed that starter home construction has slowed to a trickle solely due to land use policy — the lots are too damn big! — while disregarding all other factors that impact home construction in today’s economy. In short, blame local government, and bring down the hammer of a statewide, one-size-fits-all solution. The voters of Massachusetts deserve better, and they said so.

It’s true that local zoning changes were happening at the same time that home prices were taking off in Massachusetts, but claiming that one caused the other ignores the myriad factors that affect the marketplace. A lot has changed since the starter home heyday of the 1960s, when a gallon of gas cost 30 cents and a modest new home cost $15,000.

With this in mind, let’s review the shortcomings of approaches like Question 7:

• Construction costs: The cost of materials for building a new home has climbed by 50 percent since 2019, according to industry experts. The prices of concrete for foundations, lumber for framing, and appliances for kitchens spiked after the COVID pandemic and spiked again due to recent tariff policies. On top of this, the labor market is particularly tight in the building trades, forcing developers to increase wages, which again adds to costs. The demands of ever-tightening building codes drive prices even higher.

“The cheapest house that you could possibly build is still not a starter, what somebody would call a starter house,” Chris Lyons, a 48-year-old developer from East Bridgewater, told MassLive for a Question 7 postmortem. “The actual economy of it is that you’re going to build $800,000 houses. This isn’t the 1960s. … That’s not how it works.”

Question 7 brushed aside this reality and omitted affordability guardrails, leaving it to for-profit developers to determine the size and price point of homes that would have been built. In a high-demand market, this would simply mean more high-end housing. If we want to get serious about creating entry-level homes, construction costs are the elephant in the room.

• Asking voters to vote against themselves: The voters who were asked to support Question 7 are the very same voters who make zoning decisions in their communities — at town meetings in 292 towns and through their representative councils in 59 cities. Asking them to support a proposal that removes their input from the equation is a fool’s errand.

The grounding principle of the state’s approach to zoning is that local leaders and residents are best positioned to make decisions about the future of their communities. Municipal leaders are more accountable to the public than any other level of government. Their constituents bend their ear at the grocery store, the local coffee shop, and the soccer field. Municipal leaders are intimately familiar with what their schools, environment, infrastructure, and public services can handle. Bypassing this local expertise and input is a recipe for adverse outcomes.

• Inequitable application: Question 7 claimed to be a statewide remedy, but it required a forensics expert to determine where it would have applied and where it would not. One community would be impacted, but its neighbor would not. In many towns, the law would apply only to portions of the community. The application analysis had to drill down to individual lots.

The irony here is that any attempt to impose a one-size-fits-all rule on all communities is upended by the reality that our 351 cities and towns are indeed different. Worcester has little in common with Worthington, and efforts to treat them the same are irrational.

• Infrastructure: Question 7 was contingent on access to public water and sewer, but shrugged off the issue of capacity limits in local systems. A consequence would have been costs borne by taxpayers for costly infrastructure upgrades. For a housing solution to be effective, infrastructure must be a consideration.

• Market conditions: Massachusetts is a desirable place to live, which has driven demand, and prices, over the past half-century. More recently, private equity and institutional investors have gained a significant presence in the residential marketplace, which further increases demand for limited housing stock, driving prices higher still. Worthwhile housing solutions cannot ignore this reality.

• Effective alternatives: There are productive ways to go about kickstarting home construction. One great example is the federal 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act, which focuses on increasing housing supply, streamlining federal regulations, modernizing federal housing programs, and placing limits on large, institutional investors buying single-family homes — all without top-down mandates.

Another example is the new Move-In Mass program, which provides development financing to help build more affordable starter homes using modular, manufactured, and other cost-effective construction methods. Municipal leaders stand ready to partner on practical solutions like these.

Election Day has now come and gone, and we face the same housing crisis that we did before November 3. If we’re serious about moving the needle, we’ll need a clear-eyed assessment of why Question 7 failed. Rather than scapegoating cities and towns, let’s roll up our sleeves and dig in on solutions that can really make a difference.

Adam Chapdelaine is executive director and CEO of the Massachusetts Municipal Association.