Fields Corner in Dorchester at dusk. (Photo by Michael Jonas)

AS HOUSING COSTS rise, new development reshapes neighborhoods, and elected officials face mounting pressure to address inequality, Boston is once again grappling with a familiar question: Can economic growth be reconciled with social justice? The debate often appears new. It is anything but.

What many observers call a resurgence of progressive urban politics is, in many respects, a revival of one of the oldest traditions in American city governance: the belief that economic growth and social inclusion are not competing objectives, but mutually dependent goals.

Boston has wrestled with that tension for decades. Each generation confronts it in different forms—through debates over housing affordability, neighborhood change, downtown development, public investment, and economic opportunity. The language evolves, coalitions shift, and political labels change. Yet the underlying question remains remarkably consistent: Who benefits from growth?

That question is reshaping urban politics once again. Across Boston and other major cities, voters are demanding answers. In New York City—the global financial capital where the contrast between those flying high and those barely able to get by is especially stark—that frustration helped propel a 34-year-old democratic socialist into City Hall one year ago. And earlier this month, voters in the nation’s second-largest city, Los Angeles, delivered another victory for the democratic socialist left with the election of Nithya Raman as mayor.

In Greater Boston, where housing cost increases have outpaced income growth for many residents, these concerns are especially urgent. Can working families afford to remain in the communities they helped build? Can economic growth coexist with affordability? Can neighborhoods accommodate change without sacrificing stability? Can prosperity be shared broadly enough to sustain civic trust?

Supporters often call these leaders progressives, while critics call them ideologues. Both labels can obscure what is actually happening. Successful urban leaders rarely prevail because they fit neatly into an ideological category; they succeed because they connect broader civic goals to the practical realities of everyday life.

American cities have long produced reform movements that sought to balance growth with inclusion. Settlement house reformers, labor organizers, civil rights leaders, neighborhood activists, and urban mayors have repeatedly confronted the same challenge: ensuring that prosperity served democratic purposes rather than merely private interests.

One of the clearest modern examples emerged in Boston during the 1980s and 1990s. Mayor Ray Flynn took office as investment reshaped the city following decades of post-World War II economic malaise. Boston’s skyline was changing, downtown growth was accelerating, and economic opportunities were expanding. Yet Flynn recognized that prosperity alone could not resolve the city’s deeper divisions.

He believed economic growth and social justice were inseparable. A city that generated wealth while excluding large segments of its population from opportunity could not sustain civic trust. Likewise, a city committed to fairness yet indifferent to economic growth would undermine its ability to deliver progress. As Flynn saw it, the challenge was not choosing between growth and justice but achieving both.

That perspective shaped the major policy debates of his administration. Disputes over affordable housing, neighborhood participation, local hiring, homelessness, race, and economic development were often treated as separate issues, yet Flynn saw them as interconnected.

He rejected the idea that cities should measure success solely by cranes, towers, investment totals, or rising property values. Economic development was necessary, but not sufficient; a city also had to ask whether working families were gaining opportunities or losing ground.

To that end, his administration launched the groundbreaking Parcel 18 initiative in Roxbury—part of Boston’s first-in-the-nation parcel-to-parcel linkage program, designed to build equity and create wealth for communities of color—while granting the Dudley Street Neighborhood Initiative unprecedented eminent domain authority to assemble land for permanently affordable housing and open space. Those policies—established nearly 40 years ago—continue to guide urban development today, alongside the institutionalization and expansion of affordable housing and job-training linkage.

Were neighborhoods benefiting from investment or facing displacement? Were minority communities sharing in prosperity or watching its rewards flow elsewhere?

Those questions have grown even more pressing in today’s Boston. Median rent now exceeds $2,400 per month, among the nation’s highest, while median home prices approach $850,000 citywide and surpass $1 million in many surrounding communities.

At the heart of Boston’s current housing debate is how much affordable housing the city should require in major private developments—and whether overly aggressive mandates risk stalling construction altogether.

Amid high interest rates and soaring building costs, housing starts across Boston have slowed sharply. Critics of the city’s 2024 expansion of inclusionary zoning rules, which raised the affordability requirement in larger projects to 20 percent of units, argue that such mandates make projects financially unviable, choke off overall housing supply, and ultimately hurt everyone. Some contend that the city should slash or eliminate those requirements to jump-start construction.

Yet building only luxury housing will never advance equity or long-term affordability for most Boston residents—and residents will not support growth unless they are sure they can remain in the neighborhoods where it occurs.

Mayor Michelle Wu’s recently proposed adjustments offer a pragmatic middle path: preserving Boston’s core 20 percent affordability mandate while relaxing some payment timelines and other rules so stalled projects can pencil out and get “cranes back in the sky.” As Boston showed in the 1980s and 1990s, smart urban policy requires both unyielding equity guardrails and the flexibility to adapt to capital-market realities.

Flynn’s influence endures because the central dilemma he confronted remains unresolved. Rising housing costs, widening inequality, and fears of displacement have fostered the perception that growth primarily benefits investors and developers, leaving working residents behind.

Whether that perception is always justified is less important than the political reality it has created—a reality underscored nationally in this month’s midterm elections. Across the country, voters who feel disconnected from economic growth have grown increasingly skeptical of institutions and leaders who celebrate aggregate prosperity while households struggle to afford the basics.

Urban voters increasingly want evidence that government can shape market outcomes rather than merely react to them. That is why debates over political labels often miss the point. The future of urban politics will be determined not by whether elected officials adopt the language of progressivism, liberalism, moderation, or socialism, but by their ability to translate moral aspirations into practical results.

As I wrote in The Battle for Boston, which chronicles the struggle for racial, social, and economic justice under Flynn, Boston’s experience teaches us that cities need not choose between economic development and social justice; ignoring either is perilous. At a moment when public confidence in democratic institutions remains fragile, that lesson extends well beyond Boston—with national demands to address “affordability” shorthand for how many Americans feel squeezed and left behind by today’s economy.

Citizens support growth when they see tangible benefits in their own lives and neighborhoods. Economic development creates opportunity, but only when residents believe they can share in it. What appears to be a new political movement is, in many respects, a rediscovery of an old civic truth: Cities thrive when economic growth and social inclusion advance together.

Don Gillis is an urban sociologist and the author of The Battle for Boston: How Mayor Ray Flynn and Community Organizers Fought Racism and Downtown Power Brokers. He served as director of Neighborhood Services and Economic Development under Flynn from 1984 to 1993.