It’s not often you find the state Democratic Party, whose members control Beacon Hill, the state Republican Party, which often agitates against the majority, progressives who love to criticize the status quo, and influential labor unions all in agreement about a specific policy.
But that unusual confluence is exactly what’s happened as voters prepare to decide whether Massachusetts should reshape its system for electing candidates.
Both major parties, labor groups with significant political muscle, and groups that want to push state government to the left have all signaled opposition to a ballot question that would scrap the existing Democratic and Republican primary elections, replacing them with a single contest featuring candidates from all parties.
Proponents of the measure on the November ballot argue that an “all-party primary,” after which the top two vote-getters would face off in the general election, can counter some of the most corrosive dynamics in state politics, especially a widespread lack of competition.
Yet opponents suggest the impact would be the opposite, making it harder for first-time candidates to get a foothold and elevating the influence of moneyed interests. And different members of the “vote no” coalition all think the idea would disadvantage their own slice of the political spectrum.
“Hating jungle primaries,” as all-party primary structures are sometimes dubbed, “is maybe the most bipartisan issue in America,” said Jordan Berg Powers, the chair of the campaign committee urging voters to say “No on 3.”
Political insiders have been skeptical about the proposal since it emerged last year, and the opposition campaign formally launched earlier this month.
Early members include the Massachusetts Democratic Party, whose governing body voted in April to oppose the question, groups that lean further to the left like Progressive Mass and Act on Mass, and half a dozen unions, such as the American Federation of Teachers Massachusetts chapter and 32BJ SEIU. The Massachusetts Republican Party is not officially a member of the coalition, but it “firmly opposes” the ballot question.
“This misguided initiative would undermine core democratic principles by eroding the ability of political parties to select their own nominees, marginalizing smaller parties, stifling ideological diversity, suppressing general-election turnout, and amplifying the role of big money while disadvantaging grassroots efforts,” MassGOP chair Amy Carnevale said in a statement.
Many of the skeptics agree with proponents’ assessment of Massachusetts politics: too much power is concentrated at the top and too many races go uncontested, they say, allowing lawmakers to grow complacent.
“It’s not that our current system is good. It’s that this alternate one is worse,” said Jonathan Cohn, policy director for Progressive Mass.

