The proposed merger of NStar and Northeast Utilities is starting to get interesting.

What started out as a fairly straight-forward merger proposal is fast becoming a game of regulatory chess between the administration of Gov. Deval Patrick and NStar, a well-connected utility whose top executives backed Republican Charlie Baker in the last gubernatorial election.

NStar and Northeast want to combine to form a $17.5 billion behemoth with a footprint extending from Connecticut to the Canadian border. The companies say their marriage would reduce costs and enable them to do a better job of marshalling resources for major capital projects. The new company would still be subject to state and federal regulatory review.

The two utilities have been slogging their way through a variety of regulatory proceedings at the state and federal levels, but the biggest hurdle appears to be the Massachusetts Department of Public Utilities. Early this year, the DPU, acting on a request from the Patrick administration, adopted a new standard for its merger review. Instead of the old standard of “no net harm,” the new standard requires the utilities to demonstrate how their merger would yield net benefits, including advancement of the state’s clean energy goals.

Late last week, the Patrick administration tossed a wrench into the proceedings. Officials from the Division of Energy Resources proposed that the DPU put off action on the merger until NStar’s rates receive a thorough regulatory scrubbing.  The agency says NStar’s rates haven’t been subject to a public review in more than 20 years. NStar’s distribution costs – the cost of delivering electricity to customer homes and businesses – is nearly 70 percent higher than what National Grid charges.

Many administration officials privately say the DPU used to be a rubber stamp for NStar, approving perks and benefits not available to other utilities. Those days are now gone, symbolized by a late-2009 DPU decision barring NStar from collecting any of the $33 million it says it was owed for implementing cost-saving initiatives. Sources say that decision prompted a round of angry calls between NStar executives and administration officials.

Caroline Allen, an NStar spokeswoman, calls the Patrick administration’s request for a rate review, coming months after the merger with Northeast was announced, unprecedented. She also cautions that comparing distribution rates among utilities is difficult, noting half of NStar’s lines are more expensive to maintain because they are underground.

An NStar rate review is already scheduled for next year. It would be nice to have it done before the merger, but is it really necessary? My guess is that the Patrick administration is just playing hardball with NStar. The question is why. No one knows for sure, but speculation keeps returning to Cape Wind.

National Grid has agreed to buy half of Cape Wind’s power output, but Cape Wind still needs a buyer for the other half. NStar, its rates already high, has shown little interest in buying high-priced wind power. “We would hope any decisions on Cape Wind would not impact any decision on our merger,” Allen says.

But speculation that the merger review is linked to Cape Wind continues to grow, most recently on Monday in an op-ed piece in the Wall Street Journal written by Robert F. Kennedy Jr., an environmental lawyer and scion of the Kennedy family, which has long opposed locating wind turbines off the coast from its Hyannis Port compound. “In effect,” writes Kennedy, “the state administration is trying to hold hostage the proposed NStar-Northeast Utilities merger unless the two electric companies agree to buy Cape Wind’s power.

We’re still a long way from checkmate.

Bruce Mohl oversees the production of content and edits reports, along with carrying out his own reporting with a particular focus on transportation, energy, and climate issues. He previously worked...